What the Evidence Shows

Scotland has a strong and growing body of evidence showing what arts and creativity bring to the lives of babies, children and young people. This page gathers research and evaluation from CYAA members and partners across the sector. Each entry links to the full report or project page, where you can explore the findings in detail. We hope they prove useful in building your own case for Article 31 of the UNCRC, which upholds every child’s right to take part in cultural and artistic life.

Children's Cultural Rights:
New Research from CYAA

In 2025, Creative Scotland commissioned CYAA to lead research into what an arts strategy influenced and co-designed with babies and children from birth to 12 could look like. Two of our members, Starcatchers and Imaginate, carried out the work through desk-based study and direct consultation with babies and children.

Starcatchers and Imaginate have each published a full report, and a joint summary brings their findings together. The summary recommends that policy makers develop a standalone arts strategy for babies, children and young people which responds directly to their needs, interests and rights.

Children taking part in a creative arts activity

Photo: Impact Arts

Children taking part in a creative arts activity

Photo: Impact Arts

Impact Story: Voice of the Baby in Practice

Starcatchers and the Royal Conservatoire of Scotland have explored what it means to listen to Scotland’s youngest children. Prompted by the incorporation of the UNCRC into Scots law, their Voice of the Baby project asked how we can hear children who don’t yet have words. Artists and cultural organisations across Scotland contributed to two phases of research. The resulting report, Reflective Guide for the Arts and film series offer a rich resource for anyone working with babies and young children in arts settings. Explore the full project on the Starcatchers website.

Click the image to explore the project

Voice of the Baby project on the Starcatchers website
Read the MAKE with the Knit Shop learning report

Impact Story: Exploring the value and potential of teaching craft across the curriculum

This November 2025 report by Craft Scotland and Panel examines MAKE with the Knit Shop, a two-year teacher development project in six Dundee primary schools. Involving over 450 pupils and 18 education professionals, it used textile crafts to support Numeracy, Expressive Arts and Technologies. The project showed clear gains in pupil wellbeing and meta-skills, with 92% of pupils enjoying the activities and teachers reporting greater confidence.

Click the image to read the report.

Impact Story: Educational outcomes among Big Noise Raploch participants

Research conducted by the Glasgow Centre for Population Health has found that children and young people who take part in Big Noise Raploch are more likely to achieve positive post-school outcomes and are more likely to be in employment than those who have not participated in the programme. This most recent study is the fourth conducted by GCPH as part of the organisation’s long-term evaluation of the Big Noise model.

Click the image to read the report.

Read the Glasgow Centre for Population Health report on Big Noise Raploch
Read the Engage Scotland report on visual art and design education

Impact Story: Mapping Contemporary Visual Art and Design Education in Scotland

Published in March 2022, this report by Engage Scotland highlights innovative approaches to teaching art and design in Scotland’s schools. Through case studies, it explores how artists and visual arts organisations are partnering with schools to support creative learning. The research identifies both the challenges and opportunities for improving art and design education, offering valuable insights into teacher confidence and collaboration with galleries and artists. The findings present a compelling case for the role of art and design education in developing essential creative skills and preparing young people for diverse careers in the cultural and creative sectors.

Click the image to read the report.

Impact Story: Arts Alive

The Arts Alive report created by Scottish Book Trust offers clear evidence of the transformative benefits arts activities provide for children and young people. The report highlights improvements in confidence, communication, mental wellbeing, and social engagement. For many young people, especially those from disadvantaged backgrounds, the programme created vital opportunities for creative expression and personal growth. This evaluation is essential for understanding the long-term value of investing in youth arts programmes.

Click the image to read the report.

Read the Arts Alive evaluations on the Scottish Book Trust website
Read the Bookbug Before Birth evaluation report

Impact Story: Bookbug Before Birth

Scottish Book Trust's 'Bookbug Before Birth' project began in 2019 to encourage parents to sing, rhyme and talk to their babies before birth. By working with practitioners across Scotland, including Family Nurse Partnership teams, Scottish Book Trust provided additional Bookbug resources to hundreds of families in the pilot year.

Click the image to read the report.

Impact Story: Starcatchers in Wester Hailes

Learn about Starcatchers' impact in Wester Hailes. From fostering parent-baby bonding to providing free play sessions, explore their variety of engagement initiatives including how The Baby Studio hosts theatre performances and artistic explorations, engaging over 807 families in 2023-24.

Click the image to read the report.

Read the Starcatchers Wester Hailes report for 2023 to 2024
Read the Positive Stories for Negative Times impact report

Impact Story: Positive Stories For Negative Times by Wonder Fools

'Positive Stories for Negative Times' by Wonder Fools. The report showcases the global participation of youth theatres and schools, with tangible outcomes of increased self-confidence and expanded cultural access for young participants, providing compelling evidence for review.

Click the image to read the report.

Impact Story: Youth Theatre Arts Scotland

Explore the long-term impacts of youth theatre participation in Scotland through a collaborative study by YTAS and SGSAH. Through surveys and interviews with eight individuals, it reveals how youth theatre shapes lives, offering crucial evidence for sector planning and advocacy.

Click the image to read the report.

Read the Youth Theatre Arts Scotland long-term impacts research report
Read the YDance Shake It Up programme evaluation

Impact Story: YDance 'Shake It Up'

'Shake It Up (2017-2020)', a four-year initiative employing dance to enhance attainment levels in primary schools across four targeted areas identified by the Scottish Government's Attainment Challenge. Evaluated by the Robert Owen Centre for Educational Change at the University of Glasgow.

Click the image to read the report.

Impact Story: Articulate

Discover how Articulate Cultural Trust supports care-experienced youth in Scotland using art, culture, and creativity to combat loneliness and enhance wellbeing. Despite challenges, the project persisted, fostering friendships, boosting attendance, and increasing engagement among participants, showcasing its positive impact.

Click the image to read the report.

Read the Articulate Cultural Trust report
Read the Station House Media Unit report

Impact Story: SHMU

Find out how Station House Media Unit (SHMU) in Aberdeen supports disadvantaged communities through cultural initiatives. Partnering with Aberdeenshire Council since 2019, SHMU offers the Creative & Digital Media Foundation Apprenticeship, empowering youth with industry knowledge.

Click the image to read the report.

Search